Packaging & Printing

Packaging schemes launch campaign to defend PRNs amid reform pressure

The Packaging Scheme Forum says the UK’s PRN system is recycling evidence rather than a tax and warns that removing it without a workable alternative could raise costs and destabilise investment.

Freya LindholmOctober 27, 20265 min read1 views

Compressed packaging bales move along a conveyor toward a recycling processing line, with an abstract verification token suggesting the flow of recycling evidence and investment.

The Packaging Scheme Forum (PSF) has launched a campaign called “Keep Packaging Recycling Working” to defend the UK’s Packaging Recycling Note (PRN) system and argue for modernisation rather than abolition. The campaign comes as media reports say supermarkets and manufacturers are working ahead of the Budget to demand that the PRN system be scrapped, with critics describing it as a packaging or plastic tax.

The PSF represents 13 of the 15 existing compliance scheme operators. It says the current system has helped the UK consistently meet statutory packaging recycling targets for three decades, providing a responsive mechanism that supports recycling businesses, encourages investment and allows producers to meet environmental obligations. The body argues that wholesale reform of the kind proposed by the food and drink sector would be a “reckless gamble with Britain’s recycling industry”.

What PRNs do in the system

At the centre of the dispute is what a PRN represents. George Atkinson, director of policy at Valpak and chair of the PSF, said PRNs are recycling evidence, not a tax paid into the Exchequer. The money, he said, flows into the recycling system through accredited reprocessors and exporters and helps make the economics of recycling work. That distinction matters to the campaign: the PSF is trying to separate the mechanism from the “packaging tax” label used by critics.

According to the PSF, £95m of PRN revenue last year was committed to new recycling infrastructure and capacity across the UK. It also says PRN revenues supported the £1bn redevelopment of the Shotton Mill on Deeside, which is intended to produce recycled cardboard packaging and tissue paper. These examples are presented as evidence that the system directs money into recycling infrastructure as well as covering compliance.

Claimed outcomes and their limits

The PSF says the PRN system has driven UK packaging recycling rates from estimates of 27–30% since 1997 to 70% in 2025, and that it currently supports recycling of around 7.7m tonnes of UK packaging waste every year. Those figures are the core of its case that the mechanism is proven at scale. They are also claims made by an industry body representing most compliance schemes, and they do not establish how much of the improvement can be attributed to PRNs alone rather than to other policy, collection or market changes.

Even so, the figures frame the reform debate. A system that handles 7.7m tonnes a year and has operated since 1997 is not a marginal arrangement. The question raised by the campaign is whether a replacement can preserve the functions that PRNs perform—channeling money to accredited reprocessors and exporters, supporting different materials when markets are weak and giving producers a flexible route to meet targets—before the existing mechanism is removed.

Risk and cost arguments

Atkinson warned that removing PRNs without a viable alternative risks destabilising financial flows into the waste management industry, undermining business and investor confidence and putting critical national infrastructure at risk. The PSF says scrapping the system without a feasible replacement risks “creating chaos” across the packaging recycling sector. The campaign is therefore not only defending the status quo; it is arguing that the transition itself carries costs that, in the PSF’s view, critics have not accounted for.

The PSF also rejects the idea that scrapping PRNs would remove costs from producers. Atkinson said the challenge of recycling enough packaging waste to meet national targets would remain, and that a fixed-cost system is likely to cost producers more than one in which the financial stimulus can change according to market need. This is a claim about how an alternative would work rather than a demonstrated outcome, but it shifts the debate from the headline cost of PRNs to the cost and flexibility of whatever replaces them.

Reform versus dismantling

The PSF acknowledges that improvements are needed, but says they do not require dismantling the existing system, which it argues would be incredibly expensive for the government to execute. Its stated reform priorities include greater transparency over how producers’ contributions are reinvested, fair competition between UK reprocessors and exporters, and stronger market confidence. Those points are narrower than the wholesale reform sought by critics, and they define the PSF’s preferred middle ground: fix the mechanism’s transparency and competition problems while keeping its revenue flow intact.

Atkinson said there is “a very big difference” between improving a system and abolishing it before anyone has demonstrated how its essential functions will be replaced, how different materials would be supported when markets are weak and how value for money for those obligated would be assured. That framing puts the burden of proof on those seeking abolition. It also reflects the PSF’s view that the current system is adaptable, whereas a new system would require large public expenditure and a transition period with little evidence of marked improvement.

What the campaign means for the debate

The campaign’s immediate effect is to organise the compliance schemes around a common message ahead of the Budget: improve what needs improving, but do not spend large sums building and transitioning to an entirely new system for which little evidence of a marked improvement exists. The PSF represents 13 of the 15 scheme operators, so its position carries weight within the existing system, though it is not the whole of the packaging recycling sector.

The broader issue is whether the UK can modernise packaging recycling without losing the financial mechanism that, according to the PSF, has supported three decades of target compliance. The campaign does not settle that question. It does, however, make the trade-offs explicit: the value of a proven revenue flow versus the cost of a transition, the need for transparency versus the risk of disruption, and the demand for reform versus the absence of a demonstrated replacement.